-
- 2006 Kicker/Punter Georgia High School Association Football State Champion (AAAAA)
- 2006 Atlanta Journal Constitution All-State Punter (AAAAA)
- 2006 Georgia Sports Writers Association All-State Punter (AAAAA)
- 2006 Georgia Coaches Association All-State Kicker & Punter (AAAAA)
- 2009 Unanimous First Team All-American Punter while playing for the University of Georgia
- 2009 Ray Guy Award Winner (Nation’s Best Punter)
- 2009 First Team All-SEC Punter
- Led National College Athletics Association in Gross & Net Punting Average
- 2010 First Team Academic All-American Punter
- 2010 Second Team All-American Punter
- 2010 Second Team All-SEC Punter
- 2010 Ray Guy Award Finalist (Nation’s Best Punter)
- 2010 Named UGA’s Team of the Decade Punter
-
- 2011 First Team Academic All American (Punter)
- 2011 William V. Campbell Trophy Finalist (Nation’s Top Scholar-Athlete)
- 2011 All-SEC Honorable Mention
- 2011 Two-Time UGA Team Captain
- 2011 All-Time Leader in Career Punting Average at UGA
- 2011 One of seven players in UGA Football history to be named an Academic & Athletic First Team All-American.
- 2011 One of eight players in UGA Football history to be voted a Unanimous First Team All-American
- 2012 Started all 16 games during rookie season for Pittsburgh Steelers
- 2012 Longest punt in Heinz Field history (79 yards) for Pittsburgh Steelers
- 2014 Led NFL in punts downed inside the 20 yard line while playing for the Arizona Cardinals.
- 2014 NFL Playoffs for Arizona Cardinals
- 2015 NFC West Champions (13-3) for Arizona Cardinals
- 2015 NFC Championship Game for Arizona Cardinals
Peachtree Ridge grad Drew Butler’s punting career nets Gwinnett Sports Hall of Fame Inducation